Justine Ezarik is nicknamed The Gambler. She was invited to the party by Joey Graceffa.
Episode 1 - An Invitation
Justine is happy to be at the dinner party, also confused. Justine gamble with Glozell and Tim. She is scared during Shane's death. Justine goes with Tim, Sierra, and Andrea to the library. Justine is scared when the car blows up.
Episode 2 - The Ungodly Machine
Justine uses the spirit board, which spells out "BOOKS". Justine goes with Matt, Lele, and Glozell to find the fire clue. Justine votes for Andrea to go into the basement. Justine is chosen by Andrea to help aid her through the machine. Justine doesn't take her gloves off during the ice water part. Justine doesn't save Andrea. Justine says Andrea maybe should've gone. The group is surprised by what Justine says.
Episode 3 - Buried Alive
Justine goes with Joey and Eva to get Caroline's scarf. Justine is scared during the seance. Justine goes with Sierra, Lele, and Matt to get the key. Justine finds out the music box is playing a song. Justine is scared when they unbury the coffin. Justine, along with Joey and Matt, vote for Tim to get buried. Justine says she will not go in the coffin. Justine is drawn, she tries running. Marvin, the grounds keeper, grabs her. The group carry her back, and burry her. Justine is screaming but stops, meaning she was sacrificed to the claws ritual, reversing it, exposing the artifact.