This lists all of the deaths of guests in the show, as well as who was voted into the challenge in each episode and similar information.
|Red||The guest was voted into a challenge and died.|
|Green||The guest escaped the night.|
|Pink||The guest was voted into a challenge, but survived.|
|Orange||The guest was revived.|
|Blue||The guest was asked by another guest to assist them in a challenge and succeeded.|
|Purple||The guest was asked by another guest to assisst them in a challenge, but failed.|
|White||The guest was not voted into a challenge, but was killed in a plot twist/got betrayed.|
|Yellow||The guest had immunity from the challenge and could not be voted in.|
|Teal||The guest was voted to die without being in a challenge.|
The guest survived the episode without being voted into a challenge.
|Guests||Episode 1||Episode 2||Episode 3||Episode 4||Episode 5||Episode 6||Episode 7||Episode 8||Episode 9||Episode 10|
|Joey Graceffa||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||VOTED||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||ESCAPED THE NIGHT|
|Eva Gutowski||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||VOTED||SAFE||ESCAPED THE NIGHT|
|Oli White||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||VOTED||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||VOTED||ESCAPED THE NIGHT|
Causes of death
- Andrea Brooks - Asphyxiated by toxic gases
- Justine Ezarik - Buried alive by the group
- GloZell Green - Choked after Joey wrote her name in the Murder Journal.
- Sierra Furtado - Convulsed and died due to demonic possession
- Matt Haag - Ingested poison
- Timothy Delaghetto - Shot himself in the head
- Lele Pons - Electrocuted
|Guests||Episode 1||Episode 2||Episode 3||Episode 4||Episode 5||Episode
|Episode 7||Episode 8||Episode 9||Episode 10|
|Andrea Russett||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||VOTED||SAFE||SAFE||VOTED||ESCAPED THE NIGHT|
|Tyler Oakley||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||VOTED||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||ESCAPED THE NIGHT|
Causes of death
- Jesse Wellens - Eaten alive by Jorogumo
- DeStorm Power- Shot in the chest by The Dark Army
- Liza Koshy- Throat slit by harpies
- Tana Mongeau - Stomach slashed open by the Path of Betrayal Guardian.
- Gabbie Hanna- Heart ripped out by a Promethean.
- Alex Wassabi - Stabbed in the chest by the Dark Dimension Gatekeeper.
- Joey Graceffa - Stabbed in the chest by The Sorceress, later revived by The Crown of Oblivion.
|Guests||Episode 1||Episode 2||Episode 3||Episode 4||Episode 5||Episode 6||Episode 7||Episode
|Episode 9||Episode 10|
|Joey Graceffa||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||VOTED||SAFE||ESCAPED THE NIGHT|
|Nikita Dragun||SAFE||SAFE||VOTED||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||VOTED||SAFE||VOTED||ESCAPED THE NIGHT|
|SAFE||ESCAPED THE NIGHT|
|Rosanna Pansino||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||VOTED||SAFE||SAFE||SAFE||VOTED DEAD|
Causes of death
- JC Caylen - Stabbed in the gut by the head clown
- Roi Fabito - Bitten by the Snake Woman
- Teala Dunn- Strangled and gassed to death by The Man with No Name
- Matthew Patrick - Beaten to death by the Strong Man, later revived by the Harp of Lazarus.
- Colleen Ballinger - Impaled by The Maiden of Madness
- Safiya Nygaard - Stabbed in the gut by Willy
- Rosanna Pansino - Stabbed in a ritual sacrifice
- Manny Mua - Shot by Nikita
Below are the deaths of non-guest characters that appeared on screen, not including lieutenants or extras.