FANDOM


Cult logo shadow
There are spoilers on this page! Continue with caution....
Coffin

Joey's coffin in The Sorceress.

This lists all of the deaths of guests in the show, as well as who was voted into the challenge in each episode and similar information.

Key:

Red The guest was voted into a challenge and died.
Green The guest escaped the night.
Pink The guest was voted into a challenge, but survived.
Orange The guest was revived.
Blue The guest was asked by another guest to assist them in a challenge and succeeded.
Purple The guest was asked by another guest to assisst them in a challenge, but failed.
White The guest was not voted into a challenge, but was killed in a plot twist/got betrayed.
Yellow The guest had immunity from the challenge and could not be voted in.
Teal The guest was voted to die without being in a challenge.
No Color

The guest survived the episode without being voted into a challenge.

Season 1

Guests Episode 1 Episode 2 Episode 3 Episode 4 Episode 5 Episode 6 Episode 7 Episode 8 Episode 9 Episode 10
Joey Graceffa SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE ESCAPED THE NIGHT
Eva Gutowski SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED SAFE ESCAPED THE NIGHT
Oli White SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED ESCAPED THE NIGHT
Lele Pons SAFE VOTED SAFE VOTED SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED
DEAD
Timothy Delaghetto SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED SAFE VOTED VOTED
DEAD
Matt Haag SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED VOTED
DEAD
Sierra Furtado SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED
DEAD
GloZell Green SAFE SAFE SAFE BETRAYED
DEAD
Justine Ezarik SAFE SAFE VOTED

DEAD

Andrea Brooks SAFE VOTED
DEAD
Shane Dawson DEAD

Causes of death

Season 2

Guests Episode 1 Episode 2 Episode 3 Episode 4 Episode 5 Episode

6

Episode 7 Episode 8 Episode 9 Episode 10
Andrea Russett SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED SAFE SAFE VOTED ESCAPED THE NIGHT
Tyler Oakley SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE ESCAPED THE NIGHT
Joey Graceffa SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED SAFE SAFE SAFE DEAD
Alex Wassabi SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED SAFE SAFE VOTED SAFE VOTED
DEAD
Gabbie Hanna SAFE SAFE VOTED SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED
DEAD
Tana Mongeau SAFE SAFE VOTED SAFE SAFE BETRAYED

DEAD

Liza Koshy SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED
DEAD
DeStorm Power SAFE VOTED SAFE VOTED
DEAD
Jesse Wellens SAFE SAFE DEAD
Lauren Riihimaki SAFE VOTED
DEAD

Causes of death

Season 3

Guests Episode 1 Episode 2 Episode 3 Episode 4 Episode 5 Episode 6 Episode 7 Episode

8

Episode 9 Episode 10
Joey Graceffa SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED SAFE ESCAPED THE NIGHT
Nikita Dragun SAFE SAFE VOTED SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED SAFE VOTED ESCAPED THE NIGHT
Matthew Patrick SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED
DEAD
DEAD REVIVED
SAFE

VOTED

SAFE ESCAPED THE NIGHT
Manny MUA SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED SAFE VOTED

VOTED

VOTED
DEAD
Rosanna Pansino SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED DEAD
Safiya Nygaard SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE DEAD
Colleen Ballinger SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE VOTED

DEAD

Teala Dunn SAFE VOTED SAFE VOTED
DEAD
Roi Fabito SAFE SAFE

VOTED
DEAD

JC Caylen SAFE VOTED
DEAD

Causes of death

Other Deaths

Below are the deaths of non-guest characters that appeared on screen, not including lieutenants or extras.

Death Episode Cause of death Murderer Date
Season 1
Caroline Eastwick Buried Alive Buried alive Two Groundskeepers
Sarah Betrayal At The House On The Hill Stabbed Arthur's Brother
Marvin Betrayal At The House On The Hill Stabbed Arthur's Brother
Arthur Betrayal At The House On The Hill Shot and stabbed Arthur's Brother
Season 2

Unnamed Man

Tangled Web

Eaten alive

Jorogumo

Confederate Man

A Nation Divided Shot Joey
Sampson The Gingerbread Woman Throat slit The Harpies
Torhil the Undying Endless Winter Night Poisoned The Harpies
Alison Full Moon Slaughter Ripped apart Atticus
The Sorceress The Sorceress Throat slit Riley
Season 3
Mayor Janet The Clowns Here Kill Part 1 Thrown from a balcony A Killer Clown 13th October 1978
Bahar Venomous Affections Bitten The Snake Woman 13th October, 1978
The Two Hunters The Man with No Name (Episode) Gassed Benjamin 14th February 1978
The Doll Maker Twin Dolls Stabbed multiple times The Twin Dolls 19th July 1978
Betty, Willie's Wife Funhouse (Episode) Shot Willie 13th October 1977
Lucy's Boyfriend's Aunt Control Issues Eyes ripped out Lucy 24th November 1977
Mortimer Control Issues Neck snapped The Carnival Master 13th/14th October 1978
Calliope Control Issues Strangled The Carnival Master 13th/14th October 1978
The Carnival Master The Carnival Master (Episode) Throat slit Jael 14th October 1978